
Parth Shah
Registered Valuer | CA | CPA | 15+ Years of Experience
Parth Shah is the Founder and Team Leader of the company, bringing extensive expertise in business valuation and financial advisory.
Introduction
A fairness opinion can be a mandatory part of a listed-company merger or demerger in India, but it is not a document that every scheme of arrangement automatically requires. The first question is whether the scheme falls within SEBI’s listed-entity framework and whether the transaction requires the underlying valuation report to which the fairness opinion relates.
For equity-listed entities, Regulation 37 of the SEBI Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements framework requires a listed entity undertaking or involved in a scheme under the Companies Act to file the draft scheme with the stock exchanges and obtain the required no-objection letter before approaching the court or Tribunal. SEBI’s scheme framework then links the valuation report and fairness opinion to the financial terms of the scheme.
The important distinction is between two professionals. A Registered Valuer performs the valuation and determines the relative values, share exchange ratio or share entitlement ratio where applicable. An independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker provides the fairness opinion on that valuation. The fairness opinion is an independent financial review of the valuation conclusion. It is not a replacement valuation report, a legal opinion or a guarantee that SEBI, a stock exchange, shareholders or the NCLT will approve the scheme.
My Valuation works on merger, demerger and share-exchange valuation assignments under the Companies Act framework. This guide explains when a separate SEBI fairness opinion is required, when the no-change-in-shareholding exemption can apply, who may issue each document, and what boards, CFOs and company secretaries should verify before filing a scheme.
Key Takeaways
- Listed-Entity Trigger: A SEBI fairness opinion is principally a listed-entity scheme requirement. It should not be presented as universally mandatory for every merger or demerger in India.
- Two Separate Professionals: The valuation report is provided by a Registered Valuer, while the fairness opinion is provided by an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker under the listed-equity scheme framework.
- No-Change Exemption Matters: Where a listed-company scheme results in no change in the shareholding pattern of the listed entity or resultant company, the valuation report can be exempt under SEBI’s framework and the related fairness opinion ordinarily falls away with that valuation requirement.
- Proportionate Demergers Can Qualify: A demerger where every shareholder receives shares in the resulting company in the same proportion can fall within the no-change concept, subject to the exact scheme facts and current SEBI requirements.
- WOS Mergers Can Qualify: A wholly owned subsidiary merging into its listed parent without issuing shares or changing the parent’s shareholding is a common no-change scenario.
- Independence Is Mandatory: The Registered Valuer and merchant banker must be independent. Material conflicts among themselves or with the company can undermine the independence required by the SEBI framework.
- Companies Act Is a Separate Layer: Sections 230 to 232 and the Companies (Compromises, Arrangements and Amalgamations) Rules govern the scheme and NCLT process. Their valuation language should not be confused with SEBI’s separate merchant-banker fairness opinion requirement.
- Debt-Listed Schemes Need Separate Analysis: Entities with listed NCDs or NCRPS have a separate Regulation 59A scheme framework. Do not automatically carry an equity-listed exemption into a debt-listed scheme without checking the applicable chapter and transaction facts.
What Is a Fairness Opinion in India?
A fairness opinion is an independent financial opinion on whether the valuation or transaction consideration is fair from a financial perspective to the affected shareholders or security holders. In a listed-company scheme, its regulatory role is tied to the Registered Valuer’s work.
The merchant banker reviews the Registered Valuer’s methodologies, material assumptions, relative values, exchange or entitlement ratio, capital structure and transaction terms, then reaches an independent conclusion on financial fairness.
SEBI’s current LODR Master Circular should be read with Regulation 37 and the scheme-of-arrangement requirements applicable to the listed entity. SEBI’s current legal library also reflects the October 15, 2026 LODR Third Amendment; that amendment concerns Regulation 62A on subsequent non-convertible debt listings and does not change the Regulation 37 scheme framework discussed here.
A fairness opinion should therefore answer a narrower question than the board itself must answer. The merchant banker addresses financial fairness. The board and its committees must still evaluate the commercial rationale, stakeholder impact, legal compliance, accounting treatment, conflicts and whether the scheme should be recommended.
Does Your Scheme Require a Fairness Opinion?
The requirement depends on the scheme structure, listed-entity status and whether a valuation report is required under the applicable SEBI framework.
Review Your SchemeWhen Is a Fairness Opinion Required Under SEBI for a Merger or Demerger?
For a typical equity-listed scheme that requires a valuation report under SEBI’s scheme-of-arrangement framework, a separate fairness opinion is required from an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker on the valuation of assets or shares done by the valuer. The valuation report and fairness opinion are part of the documents submitted to the stock exchanges before the scheme is taken to the NCLT.
This commonly covers share-swap mergers and non-proportionate demergers where the scheme changes ownership or economic interests in the listed or resultant company.
The practical test is the transaction mechanics: whether a valuation report is required, whether consideration or shares are issued, whether shareholder proportions change, and whether anyone enters or exits the resultant shareholding through the scheme.
| Illustrative Scheme | SEBI Valuation Report | SEBI Fairness Opinion | Practical Reading |
| Listed company merges with unrelated unlisted company and issues shares | Usually yes | Yes | Valuation supports relative value and exchange ratio; independent merchant banker opines on fairness. |
| Two listed companies merge and shareholders receive shares under a swap ratio | Usually yes | Yes | Relative values and swap ratio are financially material to both shareholder groups. |
| Listed company demerges a business with non-proportionate share entitlement | Usually yes | Yes | Shareholder proportions or economic interests change; valuation and entitlement ratio are material. |
| Listed parent absorbs wholly owned subsidiary with no fresh shares | Potentially exempt | Ordinarily no, if no-change exemption applies | Confirm there is genuinely no change in listed parent shareholding and current SEBI conditions are met. |
| Proportionate demerger with identical shareholder proportions in resulting entity | Potentially exempt | Ordinarily no, if no-change exemption applies | The exemption is fact-sensitive; verify capital structure and entitlement mechanics. |
| Purely unlisted merger with no listed entity in the SEBI scheme framework | SEBI valuation rule does not automatically apply | No universal SEBI fairness-opinion mandate | Companies Act, NCLT and other transaction-specific rules still need review. |
Source note: Decision matrix based on the listed-entity scheme framework and SEBI’s published no-change treatment. Confirm each live transaction against SEBI’s current LODR materials and the applicable stock-exchange requirements.
When Can a Listed Scheme Proceed Without a Valuation Report and Fairness Opinion?
SEBI’s scheme framework recognizes an important exception where there is no change in the shareholding pattern of the listed company or resultant company. In those cases, the listed entity may not be required to obtain the Registered Valuer’s valuation report. Because the fairness opinion is an opinion on that valuation, the corresponding fairness opinion is ordinarily not required when the valuation report itself is exempt.
SEBI’s published scheme filings show this treatment in practice. In a 2025 filing involving wholly owned subsidiaries merging into their listed parent, no fresh shares or consideration were issued and the parent’s shareholding pattern did not change. The filing stated that neither the valuation report nor the related independent merchant-banker fairness opinion was required.
The SEBI-filed scheme document is useful because it demonstrates why a blanket statement such as “every listed merger requires a fairness opinion with no exceptions” is too broad.
What Does “No Change in Shareholding Pattern” Mean?
The concept is focused on whether the scheme changes who participates in the equity and in what proportion. Historical SEBI guidance, reflected in current practice, has treated the following as changes: altering the proportion held by an existing shareholder, allotting equity shares to a new shareholder, or causing an existing shareholder to exit pursuant to the scheme.
Two commonly cited no-change examples are a proportionate demerger in which every shareholder of the demerged listed entity receives shares of the resulting company in the same proportion, and the merger of a wholly owned subsidiary into its listed parent where the parent’s shareholder proportions remain unchanged.
Do not apply those examples mechanically. Capital changes, cross-holdings, different share classes, cancellations or promoter-related features can change the conclusion. The actual scheme and post-transaction capitalization must drive the analysis.
Need to Validate the Share Exchange Ratio?
A fairness opinion evaluates whether the valuation and proposed exchange ratio are fair from a financial perspective for the relevant shareholders.
Discuss Your TransactionFairness Opinion vs Valuation Report: What Is the Difference?
| Dimension | Registered Valuer Report | Fairness Opinion |
| Core purpose | Determine value and, where relevant, relative fair value and share exchange / entitlement ratio | Independently assess whether the valuation and resulting financial terms are fair from a financial perspective |
| Typical professional under SEBI scheme framework | Registered Valuer under Section 247 and applicable valuation rules | Independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker |
| Primary analysis | Business, asset or share valuation using appropriate methods and transaction facts | Review of valuation methodology, assumptions, outputs, ratio, consideration and relevant financial information |
| Output | Detailed valuation report with workings and conclusion | Fairness opinion referencing the valuation and financial fairness conclusion |
| Independence | Must satisfy applicable Registered Valuer independence and conduct requirements | Must be independent under SEBI scheme requirements and Merchant Banker conduct standards |
| What it does not do | Does not by itself provide SEBI merchant-banker fairness opinion | Does not replace the underlying valuation report or certify legal/NCLT approval |
Source note: SEBI requires the two roles to remain distinct and independent. The current SEBI Merchant Banker Master Circular and registered intermediary framework should be checked when appointing the fairness-opinion provider.
This separation is commercially sensible as well as regulatory. The valuer develops the analytical conclusion. The merchant banker then brings an independent review lens to the financial fairness of that conclusion. If the same economic assumptions are merely repeated without genuine challenge, the governance value of having two separate professionals is weakened.
Who Can Issue a Fairness Opinion for a SEBI Scheme?
Under the listed-equity scheme framework, the fairness opinion is provided by an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker. The underlying valuation report is provided separately by a Registered Valuer. The two should not be treated as independent if there is a material conflict of interest among themselves or with the company, including relevant common directorships or partnerships.
Before appointment, the company should verify the intermediary’s registration on SEBI’s current Merchant Banker directory. SEBI’s Merchant Banker code of conduct also requires due diligence, proper care, independent professional judgment and appropriate handling of conflicts.
A Chartered Accountant, company secretary, investment adviser or Registered Valuer does not become the SEBI fairness-opinion provider merely because they are qualified in another professional capacity. The relevant SEBI merchant-banker registration must exist for the entity issuing the fairness opinion.
Likewise, a merchant banker’s fairness opinion does not eliminate the need for a properly scoped valuation by the Registered Valuer where the scheme framework requires that valuation.
What Does the Merchant Banker Review Before Giving a Fairness Opinion?
The exact work program depends on the scheme, but the fairness review should be capable of explaining why the financial terms are reasonable in light of the valuation. A careful review generally focuses on the following areas rather than simply restating the final ratio.
- Scheme mechanics: Entities, securities issued or cancelled, consideration and post-scheme ownership.
- Valuation perimeter: Businesses, assets, liabilities and instruments included or excluded from each valuation.
- Methods and assumptions: Why the selected approaches fit, and whether forecasts, discount rates, comparables and normalization adjustments are supportable.
- Relative value and ratio: How enterprise value converts to equity value and how per-share values produce the proposed exchange or entitlement ratio.
- Market evidence and conflicts: Relevant trading or transaction evidence, plus promoter, related-party and cross-holding features.
- Sensitivity and material events: Whether reasonable assumption changes or events since the valuation date could materially affect the conclusion.
The underlying merger valuation should therefore be reproducible from the report. A practical example of how enterprise value, shareholder interests and the merger ratio connect appears in My Valuation’s merger valuation case study.
Valuation Report or Fairness Opinion?
These documents serve different purposes and can involve different professionals. Confirm what your merger or demerger actually requires before filing.
Check Your RequirementsWhat Should the Valuation Report Cover for a Merger or Demerger?
A scheme valuation should do more than present a final ratio. The report needs enough analysis for the Audit Committee, board, merchant banker, stock exchange and shareholders to understand how the conclusion was reached and why the selected methods fit the transaction.
SEBI’s scheme framework expects the valuation report to support relative fair value and the share exchange or entitlement ratio where applicable. The actual methods depend on the entities and interests being valued. No single method is mandatory for every merger or demerger.
| Approach | When It May Be Relevant | Main Fairness Review Questions |
| Income approach / DCF | Businesses with supportable forecasts and cash-generation visibility | Forecast quality, discount rate, terminal growth, reinvestment and debt/cash adjustments |
| Market approach | Businesses with meaningful listed-company or transaction comparables | Peer selection, metric normalization, growth/profitability differences and control/liquidity context |
| Asset / NAV approach | Asset-heavy, investment-holding or asset-led undertakings | Asset remeasurement, hidden liabilities, non-operating assets and appropriate basis of value |
| Market price analysis | Listed shares with meaningful trading evidence | Relevant period, liquidity, unusual price movements and whether market price reflects the specific security |
A merger can require relative valuation of both companies, while a demerger can require valuation of the transferred undertaking and an entitlement ratio. In either case, the ratio should follow the valuation logic rather than be reverse-engineered to achieve a desired ownership outcome.
Illustrative Applicability Framework: Three Common Scheme Structures
The following scenarios are illustrative decision aids only. They are not legal conclusions for a real transaction and assume no additional facts that would change the applicable SEBI or Companies Act analysis.
1. Listed Company A Merges With Unrelated Company B: A issues shares to B’s shareholders based on an exchange ratio. The listed company’s ownership changes and new shareholders enter. The scheme normally requires the Registered Valuer’s report and an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker fairness opinion, along with the other listed-scheme documents.
2. Listed Parent Merges Its Wholly Owned Subsidiary: The subsidiary is already 100% owned by the listed parent and no shares or consideration are issued. If the listed parent’s shareholder proportions remain unchanged and the scheme meets the applicable no-change conditions, the valuation-report exemption can apply and the related fairness opinion ordinarily is not required.
3. Proportionate Demerger Into a Resulting Company: Every shareholder of the listed demerged company receives shares of the resulting company in exactly the same proportion. This can fit the no-change concept, but the company should verify capital structure, pre-existing shareholding in the resulting company, cancellations, related-party features and current SEBI conditions before relying on the exemption.
The decision should be documented before the scheme is filed. A later attempt to explain why valuation or fairness-opinion documents were unnecessary can delay the stock-exchange review if the capital-structure analysis was not clear at the outset.
How Do the Companies Act and NCLT Rules Fit With SEBI?
Sections 230 to 232 of the Companies Act, 2013 provide the core legal route for compromises, arrangements, mergers and amalgamations that proceed through the NCLT. Section 232 requires scheme materials to address the effects of the arrangement and the share exchange ratio, including any special valuation difficulties, and refers to the expert report regarding valuation where applicable.
Section 247 establishes the Registered Valuer framework where a valuation is required under the Companies Act and requires the valuer to act impartially, exercise due diligence and avoid prohibited interests. The statutory text is available in the Companies Act, 2013.
The Companies (Compromises, Arrangements and Amalgamations) Rules also require valuation-related disclosures in the explanatory material where applicable. Their reference to a “fairness opinion of the registered valuer, if any” should not be confused with SEBI’s separate capital-markets requirement for an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker to issue the fairness opinion on the Registered Valuer’s work for a listed scheme.
This distinction matters particularly for an unlisted merger. A merger between two unlisted companies can have a valuation requirement under the Companies Act and NCLT process without automatically creating SEBI’s listed-company merchant-banker fairness-opinion requirement. My Valuation’s valuation under the Companies Act reflects the merger, demerger and M&A swap-ratio valuation workstream.
If a listed entity is a party to the scheme, however, the Companies Act route and SEBI/stock-exchange review operate together. Completing one does not eliminate the other.
What Should the Audit Committee and Board Check Before Recommending the Scheme?
The valuation and fairness opinion are evidence for governance decisions, not substitutes for them. SEBI’s scheme framework requires the listed entity’s Audit Committee and board to consider the valuation and the rationale and impact of the scheme, while the Committee of Independent Directors has its own recommendation role under the applicable framework.
- Scope and date: Does the valuation match the latest scheme perimeter, terms and appropriate valuation date, with material events captured?
- Share counts: Do diluted shares, cross-holdings, ESOPs and instruments reconcile to the scheme and cap table?
- Method consistency: Are methods and assumptions applied consistently, with justified differences where businesses are not comparable?
- Ratio bridge: Can the board trace enterprise value to equity value to per-share value and the final exchange or entitlement ratio?
- Independence: Has merchant-banker registration been checked and are conflicts with the valuer or company cleared?
- Shareholder impact and approvals: Which holders gain, dilute, enter or exit, and what additional public-shareholder or other approvals apply?
- Disclosure consistency: Do the scheme, stock-exchange filing, valuation report and fairness opinion tell the same financial story?
Preparing a Merger or Demerger Scheme?
Coordinate the valuation, fairness opinion and scheme documentation early to avoid inconsistencies during board, stock exchange or regulatory review.
Speak With Our Valuation ExpertsWhat If the Company Has Listed NCDs or NCRPS Instead of Listed Equity?
Debt-listed entities require separate treatment. Regulation 59A and the related SEBI operational framework apply to entities with listed non-convertible debt securities or non-convertible redeemable preference shares that undertake or are involved in a scheme of arrangement.
SEBI’s debt-listed scheme framework requires, for the covered schemes, a Registered Valuer’s valuation report and a fairness opinion from a SEBI-registered Merchant Banker, with independence between the two professionals. It also contains a specific carve-out for a scheme that solely provides for an arrangement between a debt-listed entity and its unlisted wholly owned subsidiary, subject to the prescribed disclosure treatment.
Do not assume that an exemption or document rule described for equity-listed schemes transfers automatically to a debt-listed structure. If an entity has both listed equity and listed debt, the applicable requirements should be mapped together before filing.
Does a Fairness Opinion Replace Shareholder Approval or SEBI/NCLT Review?
No. A fairness opinion is one part of the scheme documentation. It does not replace the stock-exchange no-objection process under Regulation 37, shareholder voting, any majority-of-minority condition that applies to the particular scheme, creditor processes, NCLT sanction, accounting compliance or other regulatory approvals.
SEBI has specifically used valuation reports, merchant-banker fairness opinions and public-shareholder voting requirements as separate investor-protection tools. The fairness opinion supports an informed financial assessment, but it does not itself approve the transaction.
Likewise, an NCLT order sanctioning a scheme should not be described as retroactive validation of every valuation assumption. Each professional report remains responsible for the conclusion and scope it was engaged to provide.
Common Fairness Opinion Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming every merger needs one. Identify whether the listed scheme framework and valuation-report requirement actually apply.
- Ignoring the no-change exemption. A WOS merger or truly proportionate demerger can differ from a third-party share-swap merger.
- Ignoring independence. The valuer and merchant banker have distinct roles and must satisfy the applicable conflict requirements.
- Treating the opinion as a second valuation certificate. Its purpose is to assess financial fairness of the valuation and terms, not reproduce the Registered Valuer’s report.
- Reverse-engineering the ratio. The exchange or entitlement ratio should follow the relative-value analysis, not a desired ownership split.
- Mixing approvals and terminology. Companies Act valuation disclosures, SEBI fairness opinions, shareholder approvals and NCLT sanction are separate requirements.
Why My Valuation for Merger and Demerger Valuation?
My Valuation is an IBBI Registered Valuer-led valuation and advisory firm. The live site identifies CA Parth Shah as an IBBI Registered Valuer for the Securities or Financial Assets class under Section 247 of the Companies Act, 2013.
For merger and demerger assignments, the relevant My Valuation workstream is the underlying Registered Valuer analysis: valuing the entities or undertakings, reconciling enterprise value to equity value, determining relative per-share values, and supporting a defensible share exchange or entitlement ratio where required.
Where SEBI separately requires a fairness opinion, that opinion must be issued by an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker and the independence rules must be preserved. Keeping those roles explicit is more important than presenting one firm or one report as covering every regulatory requirement.
Conclusion
A fairness opinion is required in India when the applicable SEBI scheme framework calls for an independent merchant-banker opinion on a Registered Valuer’s valuation. For a typical listed-company merger or demerger that changes shareholder interests and requires a valuation report, the valuation and fairness opinion are separate but connected documents.
The requirement is not universal. A listed-company scheme that produces no change in the shareholding pattern can qualify for the valuation-report exemption and, where that exemption applies, the related fairness opinion ordinarily is not required. A wholly owned subsidiary merger without new shares and a truly proportionate demerger are common examples, but the actual scheme mechanics must be checked before relying on the exemption.
Unlisted schemes should be analyzed under the Companies Act, NCLT and other transaction-specific rules rather than automatically importing SEBI’s listed-company merchant-banker requirement. Debt-listed entities also have a separate Regulation 59A framework that needs its own review.
Need Support with a Scheme of Arrangement?
Get the valuation and fairness-opinion requirements reviewed against the structure of your proposed merger, demerger or restructuring.
Contact Our TeamFrequently Asked Questions
1. Is a fairness opinion mandatory for every merger in India?
No. SEBI’s independent merchant-banker fairness opinion is principally a listed-entity scheme requirement tied to the underlying valuation framework. A purely unlisted merger does not automatically require a SEBI fairness opinion merely because it is implemented under Sections 230 to 232 of the Companies Act.
2. Who can issue a fairness opinion for a SEBI-listed merger or demerger?
The fairness opinion under the listed-equity scheme framework is provided by an independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker. The underlying valuation report is provided separately by a Registered Valuer, and the two appointments must satisfy the applicable independence requirements.
3. Is a fairness opinion required when a listed parent merges its wholly owned subsidiary?
It may not be required if the merger results in no fresh share issue or consideration and no change in the listed parent’s shareholding pattern, so that the SEBI valuation-report exemption applies. The company should confirm the complete scheme mechanics before relying on that treatment.
4. Does a proportionate demerger need a fairness opinion?
A truly proportionate demerger can fit SEBI’s no-change concept where every shareholder receives equity in the resulting company in the same proportion and the other conditions are met. Pre-existing holdings, cancellations, different share classes or other capital changes can alter the analysis.
5. What is the difference between a fairness opinion and a swap-ratio valuation?
The Registered Valuer determines the relative values and the share exchange or entitlement ratio using appropriate valuation methods. The independent SEBI-registered Merchant Banker then reviews that valuation and opines on the financial fairness of the conclusion; the fairness opinion does not replace the valuation report.
6. Can the same firm issue both the valuation report and the fairness opinion?
The SEBI scheme framework requires the Registered Valuer and merchant banker to be independent and treats material conflicts among themselves or with the company as inconsistent with that independence. Appointments should therefore be structured so the two regulatory roles remain genuinely independent.
7. Does a fairness opinion guarantee SEBI or NCLT approval?
No. It is one financial-governance document in the broader scheme process. Stock-exchange review, SEBI observations where applicable, shareholder and creditor approvals, NCLT sanction, accounting treatment and other conditions remain separate.
8. Do debt-listed companies follow the same fairness-opinion rules as equity-listed companies?
Not necessarily. Entities with listed NCDs or NCRPS have a separate Regulation 59A scheme framework, including its own valuation, fairness-opinion and exemption provisions. A company with both listed equity and debt should map both sets of requirements before filing.
Important: This article provides general educational information, not transaction-specific legal, securities, accounting, tax or investment advice. SEBI, stock-exchange and Companies Act requirements can change with the scheme facts and current regulatory amendments. Obtain qualified legal, company-secretarial and financial review before implementation.





